Influential Article Review - Accounting Data: Shoult it be More Relevant or Accurate?

Authors

  • Danniella Jaramillo
  • Orion Bradford
  • Eira Tomlinson

Keywords:

Accounting information, Agency-problem, Limited commitment, Timeliness

Abstract

This paper examines accounting. We present insights from a highly influential paper. Here are the highlights from this paper: We consider a two-period LEN-type agency problem. The principal needs to implement one out of two accounting systems. One emphasizes relevance, the other reliability. Both systems produce identical inter-temporally correlated signals. The relevant system reports an accounting signal in the period in which it is produced. The reliable system reports a more precise signal, but with a one period delay. Accounting information is contractible only if it is reported within the two-period horizon of the game. Accordingly, accounting information produced in the second period becomes uncontractible with the reliable system in place. Non-accounting information needs to be used for contracting to provide any second period incentives at all. We derive optimal compensation contracts in a full and in a limited commitment setting. With full commitment, the reliable system trades-off more precise first and less precise second-period contractible information, as compared to the relevant system. If the reduction of noise in the accounting signals is strong and the distortion in the non-accounting measure is weak, the reliable system is preferred. With limited commitment we identify a similar trade-off if intertemporal correlation of the signals is negative. If it is positive, this trade-off might reverse: The reliable system is possibly preferred if noise reduction is small and the non-accounting measure is heavily distorted. Noisiness in performance measures then serves as a commitment device. It reduces otherwise overly high powered incentives and thus benefits the principal. For our overseas readers, we then present the insights from this paper in Spanish, French, Portuguese, and German.

Downloads

Published

2019-12-13

How to Cite

Jaramillo, D., Bradford, O., & Tomlinson, E. (2019). Influential Article Review - Accounting Data: Shoult it be More Relevant or Accurate?. Journal of Accounting and Finance, 19(10). Retrieved from https://articlegateway.com/index.php/JAF/article/view/3452

Issue

Section

Articles