The Active Versus Passive Investing Debate: Evidence From the 2018-2023 Market Cycle
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.33423/jaf.v24i4.7176Keywords:
accounting, finance, active management, passive management, Sharpe ratioAbstract
The paper investigates the research question: Which investment management style, active or passive, produced better risk-adjusted performance from January 1, 2018, to December 31, 2023 (Prondzinski, 2010)? The comprehensive time period was further subdivided into two periods: January 2020 – May 2023, the Pandemic period, and March 2022 – December 2023, the interest rate hiking period without any interest rate cuts. The study tested twenty-seven hypotheses derived from this research question for the specified periods addressed.
The study, consisting of 27 statistical tests, found that on a risk-adjusted basis, the Sharpe ratios of active indices (proxies for active management) significantly exceeded the passive indices (proxies for passive management) in nine of the periods tested) (Prondzinski, 2010).
References
Active vs passive mutual fund investing: Which one’s for you? [Strategies]. (2021, February 2). The Economic Times. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2484299193/citation/8EE4BD38E70D4F6EPQ/1
Active vs passive mutual fund schemes: What should you invest in? [Wealth-Invest]. (2020, October 27). The Economic Times. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2454203703/citation/AB21E47719E142BFPQ/1
Active vs. Passive Strategies. (2020). Planadviser. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2641593760/abstract/5159462D229A40FFPQ/1
Active vs. Passive. (2020). Journal of Financial Planning, 33(6), 19. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/trade-journals/active-vs-passive/docview/2410489418/se-2
Barrett, C. (2022). Why do we still bother with active funds? FT.Com. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2706588498/citation/C4CA6FB47CAB4C85PQ/1
Bhalla, S.A. (2022, June 13). Active vs Passive Mutual Funds: Passive is the way to go in large caps, experts agree - FE Manage Your Money. Financial Express. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2675521938/citation/1E9C056C492E477APQ/1
Boyde, E. (2022). Shift from active to passive funds is accelerating, JPMorgan says. FT.Com. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/pq1business/docview/2756984269/
Butler, D. (2019, July 12). Active vs. passive investing: What’s the difference? TheStreet. Retrieved from https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A593127352/AONE?u=lom_davenportc&sid=summon&xid=50ef94a7
Crane, A.D., & Crotty, K. (2018). Passive versus active fund performance: Do index funds have skill? Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 53(1), 33–64. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022109017000904
Dhanorkar, S. (2020, March 3). Active vs passive mutual funds: Which is better in multi-cap space? [Wealth-Invest]. The Economic Times. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2369557344/citation/E6603CF1387B426EPQ/2
Dhanorkar, S. (2023, January 17). Active vs passive mutual funds: Where should you invest? [Wealth-Invest]. The Economic Times. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2765806295/citation/E8408345F9C54FE5PQ/1
Duncan, E. (2018). Active versus passive when investing ethically. The Financial Times Limited. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2116301227/abstract/DD32B8FEC9BD4801PQ/1
Evans, B. (2023, January 25). The stock market will soon reach a tipping point in active versus passive investing, ISS says. Business Insider, US Edition. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2769312700/citation/DCD8914AE4804858PQ/1
Frick, F. (2021). Competition and collaboration: Active versus passive managers. Investment Week,13. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/trade-journals/competition-collaboration-active-versus-passive/docview/2580731500/se-2
Henebry, B. (2020). Exploring the gray zone between active and passive. Journal of Financial Planning, 33(8), 41–43. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/trade-journals/exploring-gray-zone-between-active-passive/docview/2434412842/se-2
Hodari, A. (2019, February 19). Active vs. passive. Michigan Lawyers Weekly. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2185459664/citation/C1C1F1D8C2C54A1APQ/1
Hodari, A. (2019, January 3). Active vs. passive: The case for both and a place for both. Benzinga Newswires. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2164608147/citation/1480F41731544DD4PQ/1
Horstmeyer, D. (2023, June 1). Active vs. passive ETFs: How they stack up; Actively managed mutual funds lag behind passive mutual funds. We put actively managed ETFs through a similar test. Wall Street Journal (Online). Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2821360577/citation/5D5D846AF4144C3EPQ/1
Indices, S.D.J. (2022, September 6). S&P Dow Jones Indices—Unlocking the power of passive investing with SPIVA. Retrieved from https://on.spdji.com/unlocking-the-power-of-passive-investing-with-spiva-webinar-2022
Is Active vs. Passive Passé? (2022). Wealth Management. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2640067022/abstract/9058691523204CE2PQ/1
James Norrington unravels the myths in the active versus passive asset management debate. (2018). Investors Chronicle, 22. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/trade-journals/james-norringtonunravels-myths-active-versus/docview/2057609326/se-2
Kumar, R. (2021, September 15). Passive vs active mutual funds: Which is better for investment? Financial Express. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2572535618/citation/196A3AF299A847CDPQ/1
LLC, T. by C.E. (2021, November 8). Active versus passive investing: Which strategy is better? CE Noticias Financieras, English Ed. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2595509093/citation/CB804E5596FC4EF0PQ/1
LLC, T. by C.E. (2022, October 24). Active versus passive investment: Pros and cons of each strategy. CE Noticias Financieras, English Ed. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2728457444/citation/9329C9530E444181PQ/1
Lledo, M. (2021). Time to be active. Accountancy SA, 54. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/trade-journals/time-be-active/docview/2489353311/se-2
Malkiel, B.G. (1995). Returns from investing in equity mutual funds 1971 to 1991. Journal of Finance, 50(2), 549–572. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1995.tb04795.x
Malkiel, B.G. (2023, May 17). Indexing is still the best bet for investors. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from https://www.wsj.com/articles/indexing-is-still-the-best-bet-for-investors-stock-market-portfolio-managers-finance-overpriced-returns-ff67fd72
Miller, M. (2006). Active versus passive investing: Evidence from the 1995–2002 market cycle (Order No. 3205544). Available from ProQuest Central. (304907146). Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/dissertations-theses/active-versus-passive-investing-evidence-1995/docview/304907146/se-2
Morningstar. (2018). Fact Sheet: The Morningstar Style Box. Retrieved August 23, 2018, from https://corporate.morningstar.com/US/documents/MethodolgyDocuments/FactSheets/MorningstarStyleBox_FactSheet_.pdf.
Peartree, D. (2021). The latest scoring on indexing v. Active investment management. Rochester Business Journal, 36(46), 26, 28. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/trade-journals/latest-scoring-on-indexing-v-active-investment/docview/2522424175/se-2
Prondzinski, D. (2010). Passive versus active management of mutual funds: Evidence from the 1995-2008 period (Order No. 3404491). Available from ProQuest Central. (516280447). Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/docview/516280447?accountid=40195
Prondzinski, D., & Miller, M. (2018). Active Versus Passive Investing: Evidence from the 2009-2017 Market. Journal of Accounting and Finance. Volume, 18(8). Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/scholarly-journals/active-versus-passive-investing-evidence-2009/docview/2199224340/se-2
Roberts, C. (2018, February 19). Campaign for greater transparency is critical to proper governance. Pensions Expert, 17. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/magazines/campaign-greater-transparency-is-critical-proper/docview/2002871546/se-2
Sardana, S. (2018). Round one: Passive versus active. Financial Adviser, 34. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/trade-journals/round-one-passive-versus-active/docview/2121073711/se-2
Schlesinger, J. (2019, October 19). Active versus passive… What’s better?: And what’s the difference? Seemingly disparate investment styles increasingly paired together to grow your money. Winnipeg Free Press, 10. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.proxy.davenport.edu/newspapers/active-versus-passive-whats-better/docview/2306725932/se-2
Shah, I.H., Wanovits, H.M., & Hatfield, R. (2021). Uncovering investment management performance using SPIVA data. International Journal of Finance & Economics, 26(3), 3676–3695. https://doi.org/10.1002/ijfe.1981
Take your side in the active versus passive investment debate; Isas 2018; Should you use your allowance to back a tracker fund or would you prefer to take a more hands-on approach, asks Mark Atherton. (2018, March 17). The Times, 58. London, England. Retrieved from https://link-gale-com.proxy.davenport.edu/apps/doc/A531296907/GIC?u=lom_davenportc&sid=summon&xid=dc770d11
The problem with the active versus passive debate. (2018, February 5). Plus Company Updates. Retrieved from https://link-gale-com.proxy.davenport.edu/apps/doc/A526326417/ITOF?u=lom_davenportc&sid=summon&xid=e31b0f6e
What Are Passive Versus Active Funds? -- Barrons.com. (2019, March 29). Dow Jones Institutional News. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2199626400/citation/DE98E75EB9044509PQ/1
Williams-Alvarez, J. (2018). Active management ensures ‘someone is driving the bus.’ FT.Com. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2112947186/citation/BAC531A31CEE4C17PQ/1
Younes, C. (2019). Active vs passive funds. The Financial Times Limited. Retrieved from https://www.proquest.com/docview/2210821763/abstract/D6B680DBCDED4E0CPQ/1
