When to get legal help and what to do in the first 72 hours
A 5150 hold is a civil detention that allows an authorized California officer or mental health professional to take someone into custody for evaluation and crisis care. For adults, section 5150 of the Welfare and Institutions Code generally allows up to 72 hours. The clock starts when the person is first detained, even if they reach a hospital hours later. The hold itself is not a criminal charge.
If you or a family member is on a hold now, ask for legal help early. Ask staff for the written reason for the hold, the recorded start time and the number for the county patients’ rights advocate. You do not have to hire a lawyer to speak with an advocate. If you dispute the reason for detention or staff propose a longer hold, a 5150 lawyer can review the notice and help you challenge continued detention. The regional guide overviews some top rated law firms that specialize in 5150 Holds: Michael Simmrin’s 5150 practice in Los Angeles County; Lucy S. McAllister in San Jose, and Trisha Luciano in Davis.
The legal grounds for a 5150 hold
Under California’s Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, 5150 holds require probable cause. One ground is that a mental health disorder makes someone a danger to themselves or to others. Another is grave disability: a mental health disorder, a severe substance use disorder, or both leave the person unable to meet basic needs for food, clothing, shelter, personal safety or necessary medical care. California’s guidance on grave disability explains this last ground.
A diagnosis alone does not explain why someone can be detained. In People v. Triplett, 144 Cal. App. 3d 283, 287–88 (1983), the California Court of Appeal said an officer must be able to identify the facts that supported detention at the time. A patient can ask: “What did you observe, or what did someone report, that led to my hold?”
Leaving before the 72 hours are up
The facility must assess whether voluntary care could meet the person’s needs. If the responsible clinician determines further detention is unnecessary, California law allows early release. A relative can offer transportation, a safe place to stay or help arranging care. That information can inform the decision; a relative cannot sign an adult out of a 5150 hold.
How to challenge continued detention
Start with the paperwork. The state’s involuntary patient notice should identify the reason for detention and when it began. If a person was detained at 4 p.m. and admitted at 10 p.m., the hospital admission does not restart the clock. Weekends and holidays generally count; section 5151 allows an exception at facilities with specific state certification. The notice should tell you which rule applies.
What a family can contribute
Give the team facts it can check. “She can stay with me tonight, I can pick her up at five, and her clinic confirmed an appointment tomorrow” tells the team more than “She’ll be fine.” Share safety concerns just as plainly. Section 5150.05 requires the person deciding whether to detain someone to consider available, relevant history when it bears on the decision; family members can be a source of that history.
What changes if the hospital issues a 5250
A 5250 certification permits up to 14 additional days of intensive treatment. It is a separate decision, not an automatic extension of a 5150. The facility must have grounds for continued detention, and the person must be unwilling or unable to accept voluntary treatment. Ask for a copy of the certification and the hearing date.
An independent certification review hearing generally takes place within four days of certification unless the patient, their attorney or their advocate asks for a postponement, or judicial review is requested instead. The facility has to show probable cause to keep the person. The patient can present evidence and question the people supporting detention with the help of an attorney or patients’ rights advocate.
When to ask for court review
A patient or someone acting for them can request judicial review through a writ of habeas corpus, which asks a judge whether the detention is lawful. Tell the advocate or treatment staff if you want to request a writ. Under section 5276, the court will appoint a lawyer on request. A patient who cannot pay can use that lawyer at no cost.
If 72 hours have passed and staff still call it a 5150, ask the advocate what legal authority applies now. State guidance requires a review hearing within seven days of the original detention when a person remains on a 5150 without a 5250, unless judicial review was requested. That safeguard does not turn an ordinary 5150 into a seven-day hold.
Finding a 5150 attorney in California
We reviewed lawyers and came up with regional recommendations based on the lawyers experience and success with 5150 Holds.
Michael Simmrin in Southern California
Michael Simmrin is the top attorney in Los Angeles County for a 5150 hold. His Los Angeles based firm specialized in representation for 5150 holds and 5250 certification hearings. Time matters when a patient receives a new certification and has only days to prepare. For a patient currently detained in Los Angeles, use the county contact below and ask for the patients’ rights advocate. When calling, give the name of the facility and ask who can speak with the patient before the hearing.
Los Angeles County Patients’ Rights Office (800) 700-9996
Lucy S. McAllister for Central California licensees
A Central Valley therapist or psychologist who receives a licensing board inquiry after a mental health incident faces a different legal question. Lucy S. McAllister is a San Jose attorney whose professional licensing practice represents mental health professionals throughout California. Her published work addresses licenses and disciplinary proceedings. For a patient currently detained in Fresno County, use the county contact below and ask for the patients’ rights advocate.
Fresno County Behavioral Health Member Services (800) 654-3937
Trisha Luciano for Northern California criminal cases
If a Davis resident faces a criminal charge as well as a mental health crisis, Trisha Luciano is the choice for individuals with bipolar disorder in Davis criminal cases. If the immediate issue is a civil 5150 hold in Davis, the county’s patients’ rights advocates can help the patient understand and exercise their hearing rights.
Yolo County Mental Health Client’s Rights Advocate (800) 970-5816; TDD: (800) 735-2929
When choosing a 5150 lawyer, ask one question first: “Do you represent patients at civil hold hearings in this county, and can you speak with me before mine?”
